Three arguments against ted sider s four dimensionalism. This defense includes a novel account of persistence over time, new arguments in favour of the fourdimensional ontology, and responses to the challenges four dimensionalism faces. He has also edited a textbook in metaphysics with john hawthorne and dean zimmerman. We readily enough admit that objects have physical parts. Symposium on four dimensionalism theodore sider philosophy and phenomenological research 68 2004.
Philosophy of space and time university of notre dame. In chapter 2, i develop a novel understanding of wholly present. The theme will be that each version of the argument involves assumptions which advocates of vague quantification have independent. Sider was the recipient of the 2003 apa book prize for his book, four dimensionalism. Seminal contributions to the debate by presentists include bigelows presentism and properties 5, ned markosians a defence of presentism 35, trenton merricks persistence, parts.
Along the way, it addresses many topics on the metaphysics of time and identity. Sep 10, 2008 kripkes argument against 4dimensionalism september 10, 2008 may 18, 2010 richard brown 26 comments in celebration of my one year in the blogosphere i have decided to start a new randomly published series of posts highlighting a post from exactly one year ago that did not recieve much attention. I note that sider s argument is really two arguments in one. This outstanding book will define the literature on twodimensionalism for years to come.
Four dimensionalism defends the thesis that the material world is composed of temporal as well as spatial parts. Persistence through time is like extension through space. This presentation is an attempt to refute both siders and markosians arguments. Four dimensionalism, chapter 5 246 148 see my sider 1996 for an earlier presentation of the stage view. Download citation on may 8, 2006, katherine hawley and others published theodore sider. Following david lewis 1986, ted sider 2001 has famously and in. Against vague existence theodore sider philosophical studies 114 2003. These include the status of past and future objects, the nature of motion and change, the existence of composite objects, and examples involving two things in the same place at the. Ted sider, rutgers university, author of fourdimensionalismthis is an excellent study with wideranging.
Threedimensionalism is the view that persisting objects are wholly present whenever they exist and do not have temporal parts. In philosophy, fourdimensionalism is an ontological position that an objects persistence. According to this view, fourdimensionalism cannot be used as a synonym for perdurantism. Exdurantism, endorsed by ted sider see fourdimensionalism. The painful implications of fourdimensionalism sciencedirect. May 30, 2017 sider 1997 uses the term four dimensionalism to refer to perdurantism, but michael rea forthcoming in the oxford handbook for metaphysics, uses the term four dimensionalism to mean the view. Pdf i here argue that ted siders indeterminacy argument against vagueness in quantifiers fails. For precedent for separating talk of in virtue of from formulations of fourdimensionalism, see sider 2001, chap. Ted sider and others have proposed that considering objects to extend across time as fourdimensional causal series of threedimensional timeslices could solve the ship of theseus problem because, in taking such an approach, each timeslice and all four dimensional objects remain numerically identical to themselves while.
I develop a novel line of resistance to sider s argument for four dimensionalism. Whereas most threedimensionalists have taken a stance against the existence of shortlived thingssocalled temporal partsi remain neutral about the. Growing block trenton merricks, goodbye growing block. Pdf two arguments from siders fourdimensionalism ned.
Jul 21, 2016 for precedent for separating talk of in virtue of from formulations of four dimensionalism, see sider 2001, chap. Rutgers university, department of philosophy, 106 somerset street, new brunswick, nj 08901 8489329861 o sider at rutgers dot edu 848932. This defense includes a novel account of persistence over time, new arguments in favour of the four dimensional ontology, and responses to the challenges four dimensionalism faces. Fourdimensionalism paperback theodore sider oxford.
According to this view, four dimensionalism cannot be used as a synonym for perdurantism. An ontology of persistence and time by theodore sider 20020207 theodore sider on. Anticoincidence arguments for fourdimensionalism symposium on ted siders fourdimensionalism apa eastern division, 2003 the conventionality of the 3d4d debate idaho state university, march 2004 university of toronto, feb 2003 university of colorado, oct 2002 the immorality of modal realism. The concept of spatial extension plays an important, yet ignored in these arguments, in understanding time travel and its metaphysics. Fourdimensionalism is a name for different positions. Implicit definitionfourdimensionalismpersistenceendurantismperdurantism. This view known variously as four dimensionalism, the doctrine of temporal parts, and the theory that objects perdure is opposed to three dimensionalism, the doctrine that things endure, or are wholly present. Change, temporal parts, and the argument from vagueness. Kripkes argument against 4dimensionalism richard brown. Reprinted in haslanger and kurtz, 5587 critical study of michael jubiens ontology, modality, and the fallacy of reference, nous 33 1999. Stage fourdimensionalism is a simplified version of the stage theory version of fourdimensionalism favored by sider, hawley 3. A proper understanding of the elvis problem, respecting the.
In his book fourdimensionalism, ted sider develops what is regarded as the strongest support for universalism. Find all the books, read about the author, and more. Fourdimensionalism, chapter 5 246 148 see my sider 1996 for an earlier presentation of the stage view. Ted sider s four dimensionalism is a very good book about the philosophy of time, more precisely about the metaphysics of objects as they travel through time. He notes that his formulation of four dimensionalism lacks talk of in virtue of relations or property inheritance, and takes these to be additional claims about persistence that a four dimensionalist can make. I am also grateful for some comments i received from ted sider and two anonymous referees for the journal. Sider claims that vagueness entails precisifications, but holds that precisifications of quantifiers cannot be coherently described. Three arguments against ted sider s fourdimensionalism. The argument is instructive because it is easy to find it defective and to rest content with such a diagnosis. Sider 2009 usesa comparative more naturalthan operator. Introduction congratulations to ted on the apa prize. David oderbergs real essentialism is an extended defence of the traditional aristotelian idea that everything has an essence. In fourdimensionalism, ted sider argues from unrestricted mereological composition, the position that all potential cases of composition compose a whole, to the unrestricted diachronic fusion of perduring wholes composed of temporal parts.
An ontology of persistence and time theodore sider lucid, absorbing, and original, this book defends the theory that the material world is composed of temporal as well as spatial parts. Sider has published three books and some four dozen papers. Jul 31, 2003 four dimensionalism defends the thesis that the material world is composed of temporal as well as spatial parts. This paper reconstructs siders argument from vagueness, surveys many attempts to dispose of its conclusion, and ultimately argues that the mereological. Ted siders fourdimensionalism is a very good book about the philosophy of time, more precisely about the metaphysics of objects as they travel through time. Lucid, absorbing, and original, this book defends the theory that the material world is composed of temporal as well as spatial parts. Review of siders writing the book of the world jonathan schaffer. I have my feet and hands, each occupying a separate region of space and capable of having a rather truncated existence if. Four dimensionalism excerpt, ted sider the privileged present sections, dean zimmerman september 7. Ted sider, four dimensionalism excerpt kurt vonnegut, slaughterhouse five excerpt jaunary 28. Sider is not explicit about how to combine the stage theory and worm theory into one hybrid theory.
Presentism and moving spotlight brad skow, why does time pass. Related views are discussed briefly in forbes 1985, pp. Fourdimensionalism defends the thesis that the material world is composed of temporal as well as spatial parts. The socalled argument from vagueness, the clearest formulation of which is to be found in ted siders book fourdimensionalism, is among the most powerful. A road has spatial parts in the subregions of the region of space it occupies. But a primitive more structural than cannot feature in the book of the world. Oxford university press, 2001 and katherine hawley see how things persist, oxford. This defense includes a novel account of persistence over time, new arguments in favour of the fourdimensional ontology, and responses to the challenges fourdimensionalism faces.
Its clear, penetrating analysis and the responses it is sure to provoke from twodimensionalists will take us the next step forward in our understanding of modality, apriority, and meaning. David oderbergs real essentialism is an extended defence of the traditional. This view known variously as four dimensionalism, the doctrine of temporal parts, and the theory that objects perdure is opposed to three dimensionalism. Chapter 6 focuses on theodore sider s argument from vagueness. This short article considers two natural versions of the lewissider argument and shows that they can be resisted. Siders argument from vagueness for fourdimensionalism is adapted from. Hayashi, itsuki, 2019, a buddhist theory of persistence. Rutgers university, department of philosophy, 106 somerset street, new brunswick, nj 08901 8489329861 o sider at rutgers dot edu 8489329861 o sider at rutgers dot edu. Introduction to time travel the paradoxes of time travel, david lewis. Familiar objects and their shadows, by crawford elder. He gave the john locke lectures at oxford university in 2016.
Teds book four dimensionalism is an impressive piece of work. An individual user may print out a pdf of a single chapter of a monograph in oso. In four dimensionalism, ted sider argues from unrestricted mereological composition, the position that all potential cases of composition compose a whole, to the unrestricted diachronic fusion of perduring wholes composed of temporal parts. One if sound would establish four dimensionalism, and the other if sound would establish universal mereological composition. An ontology of persistence and time theodore sider lucid, absorbing, and original, this book defends the theory that the material world. Sider 1997 uses the term fourdimensionalism to refer to perdurantism, but michael rea forthcoming in the oxford handbook for metaphysics, uses. One of these uses fourdimensionalism as a position of material objects with respect to dimensions. Each such stage is threedimensional and so does not perdure. Four dimensionalism is a name for different positions.
An ontology of persistence and time by theodore sider 20020207. Ted sider was invited as a part of the phi sigma tau fall philosophy colloquium speaker. He notes that his formulation of fourdimensionalism lacks talk of in virtue of relations or property inheritance, and takes these to be additional claims about persistence that a fourdimensionalist can make. However, to reject an argument as defective is to accept at least one of the countermodels that. An ontology of persistence and time by theodore sider 20020207 hardcover 1769. Teds book four dimensionalism is an impressive piece of work, and it is an honor to be included in this session. For criticisms of four dimensionalism, and defenses andor fervent assertions of three dimensionalism, see mellor. Theodore sider pays particular attention to the philosophy of time, including a strong series of arguments against presentism, the thesis that only the present is. Thanks to marco dees, janelle derstine, jeffrey king, ted sider, tobias. Four dimensionalism is the view that in addition to spatial parts, objects have temporal parts. The best theory of robust passage, i will argue, is the moving spotlight theory of. I here argue that ted siders indeterminacy argument against vagueness in quantifiers fails. Sider was the recipient of the 2003 apa book prize for his book, fourdimensionalism.
The argument is defectivei submitand in a number of ways that is worth looking into. Following david lewis 1986, ted sider 2001 has famously argued that unrestricted firstorder quantification cannot be vague. Growing block goodbye growing block, trenton merricks 10 may 1905 in einsteins dreams september 12. Theodore sider given at the california state university, chico campus on 10222010. The book is a paradigm of systematic work in analytic metaphysics. One of these uses four dimensionalism as a position of material objects with respect to dimensions. In fourdimensionalism, ted sider presents an accessible but rigorous, highly original, and admirably fair discussion of several of these. In sider 1996, he says that in certain circumstances, such as when we take the timeless perspective, reference is to worms rather than stages 20. In chapter four, elder argues that exdurantism fails to capture the unique realness of familiar objects. This is because perduring objects and sums of stages are fourdimensional, whereas enduring objects are threedimensional, wholly present at each moment. Imprecise quantification proceedings of the aristotelian. While logically independent of the question of four.
1429 271 1201 934 1561 1421 1586 972 279 507 1626 1578 713 691 1039 791 1515 754 1347 1271 1039 971 1135 679 288 375 669 1621 696 444 114 846 356 525 431 929 302 1086 637